Creepy stories and cocktails in old St. Augustine. This nighttime crawl turns familiar bar hops into haunted-history storytelling in the historic core, with guides who bring the spooky details to life while you sip. I really like that it stays focused on real places, not fake sets.

Two things I enjoyed most: the way the guides connect each stop to specific local hauntings, and the fact that the tour includes free admission at the venues where the story action happens. One thing to consider is that the pacing can vary, and a couple departures have reportedly run short with fewer drink stops than the written plan.

If you want a fun, low-pressure way to spend your evening—part history lesson, part spooky theater—this is an easy choice. Just go in knowing the drinks are pay-as-you-go, and build in a little flexibility in case your night runs a bit shorter.

Key Highlights You’ll Care About

• Spooky stories tied to named St. Augustine sites rather than generic ghost lore
• Three scheduled drink stops (Sangrias, The Tini Martini Bar, A1A Ale Works), with story time built around them
• No drink package: you buy what you want, while the tour handles the storytelling
• Small-group format with a cap of 20 people, which can feel more personal
• Free admission included for the main story stops, so you’re not paying twice

Why This Haunted Pub Crawl Works in St. Augustine

St. Augustine is built for this kind of tour. You can feel it as soon as you hit the streets: old stone, tight blocks, and buildings that seem to have been standing through multiple lifetimes. This crawl leans into that atmosphere. Instead of rushing from one random bar to another, the evening is organized around haunted locations and then capped with a drink stop where you can reset.

At $36 for about 1 hour 45 minutes, it’s positioned as a value evening: you’re paying mainly for the guide, the planning, and the haunted-history storytelling. Drinks aren’t included, so you control how much you spend on alcohol, mocktails, or snacks.

Also, the tour is run by Old City Ghosts By US Ghost Adventures, and you’ll meet your guide at 8 Carrera St at 6:00 pm. That timing matters: it’s early enough that you’re not stuck walking in the deepest dark the whole time, but late enough that the vibe feels right.

Meeting at 8 Carrera St and What the Timing Really Means

Your start point is simple: 8 Carrera St, St. Augustine. The tour runs about 1 hour 45 minutes and returns to the meeting point. It’s close to where you’d naturally be walking anyway, so it doesn’t feel like a major transfer to get started.

Here’s the practical reality: the itinerary is laid out with time blocks at each stop (roughly 30 minutes each for the major story-drink moments). But based on real experiences shared after the fact, some departures have ended earlier than expected and may include fewer drink stops than the written plan. That doesn’t mean the tour is always like that—just that you should plan your evening with a little slack. If you’re trying to hit a separate dinner reservation right after, give yourself buffer time.

If you’re okay with that flexibility, the rest works well: the guide keeps moving, you’re not stuck in one room too long, and the story pacing matches the drink pace.

Stop 1: Sangrias Wine and Tapas Bar and the Building’s Creep Factor

The crawl opens at Sangrias Wine and Tapas Bar, where the guide sets the tone fast. The focus here is on the historic building itself—why people whisper about it, what has happened around it, and what makes the location feel like it’s always holding its breath.

This is where you get one of the tour’s best “value mechanics” moments: the admission ticket is free for this stop. You’re still paying for the guide and the overall experience, but you’re not also paying a venue fee just to hear the story.

What I like about starting here is the rhythm. You get an intro to the setting, then you’re in a real tasting-and-snacking environment for the first drink. Since drinks are pay-as-you-go, you can choose something light (a glass of wine or a cocktail) or keep it simple with tapas. Either way, this stop gives you an easy entry into the theme.

One small drawback: because this stop is story-heavy at the start, arriving on time helps. If you’re late, you can end up waiting around while the guide is already building momentum.

The Haunted House Moment at Cas de la Paz

Between the first drink stop and the next, you’ll hear stories connected to Cas de la Paz, described as one of the most haunted houses in St. Augustine. This part leans into explanation and questioning—more than just scary details for the sake of it.

Why this works in a pub crawl format: it gives your mind something to chew on between drinks. Instead of thinking, Okay, more bars, you think, Why is this building infamous, and what patterns show up in the accounts?

This isn’t a passive side quest. The guide’s storytelling is structured to keep you engaged, including time for your questions. If you like ghost stories where the guide tries to connect rumor to location, this segment is the one to watch closely.

Stop 2: The Tini Martini Bar and How Cocktails Become Part of the Story

Next up is The Tini Martini Bar, and the guide shifts from haunted-house lore to what you’re actually drinking. You’ll get the vibe of a cocktail lesson—what makes a good cocktail, and how martinis and cocktails helped shape the feel of old St. Augustine.

This is also the spot where you can treat the night like a mini tasting. Since the tour doesn’t include drinks, you can order at your comfort level and still stay fully in the experience. If you’re the type who likes to pick a specialty drink, this is a fun moment to do it. If you’re not a martini person, you’re not trapped either; you’ll have choices at the bar.

I especially appreciate this mix because it prevents the crawl from becoming one-note. One minute you’re hearing about hauntings; the next you’re learning why certain spirits and cocktails became part of the culture. It’s entertaining, but it also makes the night feel thoughtfully built.

Cathedral Place Office Building: Where the Stories Turn Toward Real Workplace Accounts

Then the mood tightens at Cathedral Place Office Building, described as an inconspicuous office setting with well-known hauntings. The guide focuses on accounts tied to working people there, including a story involving a bank worker.

This stop is a good reminder that the “haunted” part isn’t just about old houses and dusty attics. It also lives in places where people go every day—hallways, stairwells, and office routines—making the eerie stories feel closer to home.

If you tend to enjoy hauntings that sound documented or grounded in repeated accounts, this is likely the most unsettling segment. The guide frames it as real-world reports, not just one-off spooky legends.

Stop 3: A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom and the 1600s Footprint

You end with A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom, where the guide ties the building to the site’s origins dating back to the 1600s. Instead of just finishing with a last drink stop, this segment brings you back to the sense of layered time that St. Augustine is known for.

You’ll also hear personal encounters that remain unexplained—kept in the same storytelling tone as the earlier stops. The goal here is to leave you with the sense that you’re watching history unfold, not just hearing a script.

This is a smart ending for a pub crawl. You’re already in the mode of ordering drinks and food, and you can decide how you want to close your night. If you want to keep hanging out after the tour, this is the kind of place that works well for it.

The Guides Matter: Misty, Holly, and Scott’s Styles

A big chunk of why this tour earns strong marks is the guide presence. You’ll see names like Misty, Holly, and Scott showing up in past experiences, and the pattern is consistent: the guide stays animated, mixes humor with pacing, and keeps the history + hauntings connected to real locations.

One of the best perks in the shared experiences: sometimes the group is extremely small, turning the tour into something close to a private walk. When that happens, it’s easier to ask questions and feel like the guide is adjusting to you rather than performing for a crowd.

That said, even with a small group, this is still a timed event. So if you’re hoping for a slow, long chat at every corner, understand the schedule is built around moving.

What’s Included (and What You Pay For Yourself)

Included in the price:

• Local guide
• Well-researched history
• Chilling stories based on actual experiences
• Free admission ticket(s) for the story-focused venue stop(s)

Not included:

• Drinks (you buy your own)
• Gratuity for your guide

The practical takeaway: the $36 is not a full bar tab. It’s a storytelling + guide package with free entry where it matters most. That’s often better value for people who don’t want a forced drink minimum. You can keep costs under control by choosing one drink plus food, or you can go heavier if that’s your style.

Who This Tour Fits Best

This is a great fit if you:

• want a fun evening that mixes history with scary stories
• like guided storytelling more than you like wandering on your own
• enjoy structured nights where the logistics are handled and you focus on the vibe

It’s less ideal if:

• you need strict timing to the minute (there have been reports of earlier endings)
• you expect a big, multi-pub drinking session regardless of how the night runs
• you dislike ghost stories that lean toward real-world accounts

Value Check: Is $36 a Good Deal?

For the price, you’re paying for a guide, organized haunted storytelling, and free admission at the main story venue. If you like both history and atmosphere, $36 for roughly 1 hour 45 minutes is fair.

Your biggest value lever is what you order. Because drinks aren’t included, the total cost can swing depending on how much you drink. I’d budget for at least one drink and expect you’ll add snacks if you’re hungry, since you’ll be at bars/taprooms.

And remember: since there have been reports of only two drink stops on some departures, your best “value insurance” is mental flexibility. If you treat it as a storytelling crawl first, the drinking part will still satisfy.

Should You Book This Booze & Boos Crawl?

I think you should book if you want a guided night out that feels like St. Augustine’s haunted energy is being pointed at you in real time. The story venues, the free admission at the start stop, and the guide talent (with names like Misty, Holly, and Scott tied to standout experiences) make it a solid way to spend an evening downtown.

Skip or reconsider if your schedule is tight or you need a guaranteed drink-stop count with exact timing. Plan a little buffer after the crawl, and you’ll avoid most of the disappointment that comes from expecting a perfectly rigid program.

FAQ

How much does the St. Augustine Booze & Boos Haunted Pub Crawl cost?

It costs $36.00 per person.

How long is the tour?

The duration is about 1 hour 45 minutes.

Where does the tour start?

You meet at 8 Carrera St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA. The tour also ends back at the meeting point.

What time does the tour begin?

The start time is 6:00 pm.

What’s included in the price?

The tour includes a local guide, well-researched history, and chilling stories based on actual experiences. Admission tickets for the story stops are listed as free.

Are drinks included?

No. Drinks are not included, and you buy your own drink.

How many drink stops are planned?

The described plan includes three drinking venues: Sangrias Wine and Tapas Bar, The Tini Martini Bar, and A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom.

Does the tour use a mobile ticket?

Yes, the tour uses a mobile ticket.

Is the tour available in English, and is it limited to a group size?

It’s offered in English, and the maximum group size is 20 travelers.

Can I cancel if plans change?

Yes. It offers free cancellation if you cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. If you cancel less than 24 hours before the start time, the amount paid is not refunded.